The Situation Is the First Question

Discover more: YouTube · All videos

The situation is the first question. Not the candidate.

Most executive searches that fail do not fail at the candidate. They fail because nobody diagnosed what the situation actually demanded before the search began. In this episode of Kaelon's Supernova podcast, Sophie Vurpillot sits down with Álvaro Carcel Ribes, Partner Iberia at KINT, to unpack the discipline he calls Situation Management: reading what a leadership moment actually requires before a single name goes on a shortlist.

Álvaro began his career as a lawyer, and that background still shapes how he works, anticipating risk, breaking down ambiguity, and asking where a decision could go wrong before it does. The conversation moves from his path into executive search to the shift now reshaping the field: from 'can you find the right person?' to 'can you help us make the right leadership decision for our next phase?'

Along the way they cover the four situations that demand different kinds of leaders, hypergrowth, turnaround, post-merger integration and expansion, why boards and PE partners so often misdiagnose the situation behind the brief, and the real cost of getting it wrong, a mistake Álvaro estimates can reach three times a leader's annual salary once time, severance and rehiring are counted.

The takeaway is the line his whole practice rests on: spend more time defining the problem than evaluating the candidate.

Álvaro Carcel Ribes:
Álvaro Carcel Ribes is Partner Iberia at KINT, a boutique executive search and interim management firm headquartered in Paris. He works with CEOs, C-level executives, PE partners and family business owners on leadership transitions where the situation is unusual or contested: PE-backed transformations, family business succession, the wrong C-suite during a scaling phase, a board that cannot agree on the brief. With more than a decade in executive search and talent assessment, he has led mandates at C-level, General Management and Director level, across Sales, Marketing, HR, Operations and Supply Chain, Finance and Strategy. His work spans Pharma and Healthcare, FMCG, Retail and Fashion, Luxury and Tech, with mandates across Spain and Iberia, Europe, the US, Asia and LATAM, for companies from mid-sized businesses to Fortune 500 multinationals. At KINT he operates inside a hybrid Leadership Advisory model that brings Executive Search, Interim Management and Leadership Assessment under one roof, where the right intervention depends on the situation: sometimes a permanent hire, sometimes an interim leader who buys time and information, often an assessment that reframes what the search should be.

Resources
• Manifesto: The situation is the first question, not the candidate
• LinkedIn
• KINT
• The First 90 Days, by Michael D. Watkins